Real Estate Specialists

Tabitha Strickland

Tabitha joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2019 and is the Market Leader for the Titusville office. She was born, raised, and resides in Titusville, PA. Tabitha is based out of our Titusville office and handles real estate closings, primarily, throughout Crawford, Erie, Forest, Venango, and Warren Counties. Tabitha was married in 2022 and is the former Tabitha Peterson. She studied the Paralegal Business Administration Program at Clarion University and has over 23 years of real estate closing and document preparation experience. She is a Licensed Title Agent and Notary Public. She can be reached via phone at work: (814) 213-0443 x 218, on her cell: (814) 720-3023. You can also find her on LinkedIn.

Christopher McCann

Chris joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2021 and became a Licensed Title Agent in 2024. He is the Market Leader for the Meadville and Conneaut Lake offices. Chris is a 2018 graduate of Thiel College, where he studied Business Administration, with a specialization in Marketing and Advertising. Chris is a Notary Public. Outside of work, he enjoys spending time with his family and being outdoors, hunting and fishing. You can call or text Chris at (814) 720-0550.

Katie Sayers

Katie joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2023 as a Licensed Title Agent and Notary Public. She is the Market Leader for the Erie office and brings with her over 25 years of real estate closing experience. She was born, raised, and resides in Erie County, PA, graduating in 1996 from Gannon University with a major in Paralegal Studies. Katie spent most of her career in law firms working in various areas of law, including the handling of real estate closings. Outside of the office Katie, along with her husband, is likely to be found on the sidelines of football and soccer fields cheering on their two boys. She also enjoys playing pickleball and DIY projects. Katie works out of our Erie Office and can be reached at: (814)213-0443 x221, on her cell: (814)795-2589. You can also find Katie on LinkedIn.

Lindsey Wiard

Lindsey joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2022 and is a native of Meadville, PA. She is a 2009 graduate of Saint Francis University and a 2013 graduate of Edinboro University's Business-Accounting program. Lindsey is a Licensed Title Agent, as well as a Notary Public. Her prior experience includes working as a mortgage loan coordinator and a construction project coordinator. She also owned and ran a business with her husband in North Carolina for five years. Outside of work, she enjoys spending time with family, reading and being outdoors. You can call/text Lindsey at (814) 550-4438.

Jessica Hodges

Jessica Hodges (formerly Jessica Fox) joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in January of 2023, after spending 7 years in Oregon and Virginia. She is a 2009 graduate of Juniata College with a degree in Intercultural Communication and a 2016 graduate of Butler County Community College with a Physical Therapist Assistant degree; she is also a Licensed Massage Therapist. Her prior experiences in healthcare and financial aid have given Jessica many years of customer service experience with a good business orientation towards client success. Outside of work, Jessica enjoys spending time with her husband, Pierce, children, Joshua and Aurelia, and her dog. She loves to hike, workout, bike and generally be outdoors no matter the weather! You can call or text her at (814) 439-5752.

Alyson Thompson

Alyson joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2023. She is a 2005 graduate of Pennsylvania College of Technology, where she studied Landscape/Nursery Technology with a concentration in Design and Business Management. She spent her early childhood in the Sharon/Hermitage area, but has resided in Titusville for the last 28 years. She has 15 years of banking experience, giving her a background in operations and extensive customer service experience. Outside of work, she enjoys spending time with her husband, Ryan, and two children, Brayden and Brinley, as well as their two dogs, Butch and Ellie. She also enjoys doing anything outdoors, as well as baking, cooking, and crafting. You can call/text Alyson at (814) 439-5754.

Nichole Vennare

Nichole joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2023. She attended Stephen F. Austin State University in Nacogdoches, Texas before moving to Pennsylvania in 1994.

She worked in the mortgage lending area for several years before taking time off to start a family. Outside of work, Nichole enjoys spending time with her family, boating on Conneaut Lake and camping. You can call or text Nichole at (814) 439-5753.

Casey Chapman

Casey joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in the summer of 2025. A native of Saegertown, he attended school there and is a 2016 graduate of Slippery Rock University. Casey and his family lived in Nashville, Tennessee, for five years before returning to the area. He enjoys spending time with his wife and two children, working in the yard, and is beginning to explore DIY automotive maintenance. Prior to joining ARS, he operated a small business for five years, developing strong organizational and interpersonal skills. Casey is excited to be part of the ARS team and looks forward to helping clients navigate the title process with care and attention. He can be reached at 814-720-2639.

Keith Beers

Keith joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in the summer of 2025. He was born, raised and recently relocated back to the Titusville area. Prior to joining ARS, Keith served as the hospital manager of a local veterinary hospital, building strong relationships with each of his clients. Outside of work, Keith enjoys spending time with his wife, Maureen, and their two dogs, Ace and Remi. He works out of our Titusville office and can be reached at (814) 795-4266.

Jennifer Keinath

Jennifer joined Allegheny Realty Settlement in 2025, bringing with her several years of experience as a licensed title agent and real estate paralegal. A notary public with nearly 25 years of law firm experience, she began her career in real estate preparing title searches and has built a strong foundation in settlement services.

Originally from Buffalo, New York, Jennifer moved to Erie, Pennsylvania, in 2015, where she continues to grow her career while raising six sons, ranging in age from 22 down to an infant. Outside of the office, she enjoys photography and spending time at the beach.

Ashley O'Shurak

Ashley joined Shafer Law Firm in 2014. She is currently the Operations Manager for SLF and ARS and works closely with Attorney Gary Alizzeo in his legal practice. She has a bachelor's degree from Gannon University and a master's degree from Edinboro University. She earned the Certified Legal Manager credential from the Association of Legal Administrators in 2018 and is also a Notary Public and Licensed Title Agent.

Ashley was born, raised, and currently resides in Meadville with her husband, Danny, and two children, Harper and Hunter. Outside of work, Ashley enjoys volleyball and golf and is an avid reader. She also loves watching her children during their myriad of extracurricular activities.

Attorney Jaclyn Millin

Attorney Millin was raised in Conneaut Lake and attended Conneaut Lake High School. She attended Allegheny College earning a B.A. in Political Science. Jaclyn graduated from Capital University Law School in 2019 and returned to Conneaut Lake to serve the community in which she grew up. She has a diverse practice, with real estate law being a primary area of focus for her. She is also a Licensed Title Agent.

Real Estate Specialists